sjuncal -> (7/9/2000 1:12:00 AM)
|
1) SPR, no more effecting brutal protrayal of infantry combat exists. I cried during, leaving and driving away from the theater... No other movie has ever done that to me.
2) A Bridge Too Far, second only to SPR IMHO for stark honest treatment of WWII combat, also for non-black and white portrayals of British, and German officers (the US officers are a little stereotyped however) Gene Hackman as the Polish General does a fine job of treating the Poles with the respect they deserve.
3) Kelly's Heroes, the best outragious "misadventure" movie ever made. As a movie about a war it's a farce. Fortunately it doesn't pretend to have that asperation, but as a movie about crazy things that humans do when under crazy conditions it's splendid.
4) Hamburger Hill, without question in my mind the best movie about Vietnam, it's treatment of Combat rivals SPR and matches or exceeds ABTF. The Sergeant at the end walking back to his fellow Sergeant's position a dying human wreck, is so pitiful and effecting that I well up just thinking about it. The fact that his combat took place off camera, the knife in his hand, the matted blood on his neck, leaving it up to the imagination of the viewer as to what transpired, makes the scene all the more terrible and devistating. Also has probably the most horrible vision of "friendly fire" of any movie I've ever seen.
Frankly the rest of my list pales (IMHO) in comparison to the above, and is pretty similar to the lists already offered.
Simon
|
|
|
|