Ambassador -> RE: OT: WWII Pacific theater films (12/28/2020 10:53:06 PM)
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: RhinoDad Based on some of the recommendations thought I would give the new Midway movie a go. It is said they aimed for realism but wonder how well a technical advisor in a very different military with very different training and experience will be able to capture the way of life, attitudes, and outlook of a completely different time and place. Will be very interested in how they handle Spruance's launching of an uncoordinated attack on the Japanese fleet, and other tidbits of the battle and lead up that I find interesting. But looking forward to it. Very much enjoyed “Flags of Our Fathers”, and “Letters from Iwo Jima” (may have gotten the names wrong) I have just finished watching Midway. There are a couple of mistakes off course, but extraordinarily less than its ‘70s namesake or that 2001 BS movie. The acting was a bit cliché, or downright bad for some recycled singer, and I found Harrelson’s act to be slightly wooden too (pardon the pun, I won’t do it again). What really put me off was the raid on the Marshalls-Gilberts - while I was happy to see it depicted (it’s quite rare), the landscape was ... let’s not dwell too much on that, I don’t want to make a mountain out of a molehill (sorry, couldn’t resist). But, why ? However, let’s say I still learnt some things, mainly about Best and the Gaido guy’s action during the early battle. And at least there was no romantic plot tumor, with only minor scenes to show Layton’s and Best’s mindsets. So, overall I wouldn’t rate it equal to Greyhound, which I watched recently, but way better than what Hollywood has showed us.
|
|
|
|