Culiacan Mexico
Posts: 8348
Joined: 11/10/2000 From: Bad Windsheim Germany Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: m5000.2006 Interesting comparison here ---> http://militaryhistorypodcast.blogspot.com/2007/02/ancient-rome-and-modern-america.html I've been wondering if there are any other possible similarities. Loss of Military Strength is particularly interesting. Although, I'm not sure if it's exactly true. War in Iraque isn't popular in the USA, but does that mean it is a nail in their coffin. I think not. Also, is the USA really 'overextended' militarilly? One of the problems Ancient Rome had was their strange reluctnace to use horsemen on a large scale, Roman armies relying strongly on infantry. In other words, they would refuse to make progress sticking to their traditional way of waging wars. It seems not to be true of modern US Army. I read some of the comparisons... the writer is clueless (to put it politely). • Loss of Identity • Rome: Germanization of Army and empire • America: Hispanic Immigration boom into army and country Hispanics in the US enlist in the United States Marine Corps at the highest rate of any minority. When you join the Marines you lose your identify and receive a new one. • Loss of Unity • Rome: Eastern and Western Roman Empires • America: Country vs. City, Democrat vs. Republican Ridiculous, in comparison to France or Germany (I am living here now) American politics are homogenous. • Loss of Economic Strength • Rome: Lack of gold, lack of exportable goods, income disparity • America: Outsourcing, economic decline, income disparity Not based on statistic. • Loss of Military Strength • Rome: Overextension, Middle East problem • America: Overextension, Iraq Uniformed conclusion. • Loss of Population • Rome: Plague, Lead Poisoning • America: Avian Flu, Obesity Population growth is up in the US. • Loss of Environmental Security • Rome: Salinization of North Africa • America: Lack of oil security, global warming Stupid. • Loss of Civic Virtue: o Rome: Laziness Incorrect. Statistically, the average American works longer and harder than most other people do. This is purely an informational episode. I am not trying to persuade anybody or make any generalizations or make any predictions about the future. I am trying to support famous claims, but this does not mean that these claims are foolproof. Feel free to comment with your opinions. ----------------------------------------------------- Obviously an uniformed opinion based on ignorance.
< Message edited by Culiacan Mexico -- 4/24/2007 11:19:08 AM >
_____________________________
"If you love wealth greater than liberty, the tranquility of servitude greater than the animating contest of freedom, go home from us in peace. We seek not your counsel, nor your arms. Crouch down and lick the hand that feeds you. May your chains set lig
|