Charles2222
Posts: 3993
Joined: 3/12/2001
Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: roeddog
quote:
ORIGINAL: Charles_22
quote:
ORIGINAL: Skip_Reed
quote:
ORIGINAL: Charles_22
quote:
ORIGINAL: HansBolter
quote:
ORIGINAL: Raverdave
Small ? Ha ! You could fit all of europe and the middle east into OZ and still have room left over.
Please enlighten an ignorant Yank.
I was under the apparently mistaken impression that OZ was the mythical, mystical place the twister carried Dorothy and Toto off to. 
Very appropriate emoticon there Hans, only I don't recall Dorothy doing in spin-dancing therein, but I could be wrong. Surely there must be a WoO historian among us? What are we to do if we do not?
I may not be a WoO historian but any child of the 40's and 50's can tell you of the enchantment of seeing the House spin off into the air with Margret Hamilton changing into the Wicked Witch of the West from the nasty schoolteacher in black and white and suddenly being greeted by a color version of OZ!! Magical! After having to use our imagination for so many years  (Book 1900, Film 1939 re-released 1949, 55, & Color TV 1956) So tis only a figure that Dorothy and Toto did the spinning though they were in a spinning house and can be said to have spun without contradiction.
But they could had been in the house, spiining in the opposite direction, such as it would appear in the house. But if you could see through the house, reverse spinning would place them on some sort of paradimical standstill, such that they appeared not to be spinning, or so I reason , such that the people spinning would work as an effective counter-balance to the house spinning. You doubt me? Well how do people spinning in such a house, without counter-spin, otherwise come out of it without even a headache?
I wasn't born until '59, but though WoO was a pretty decent movie, especially for kids, "Somewhere over the Rainbow" song as sung by Judy had to be one of the most beautiful iconic songs ever sang. I don't know if the writer of that song meant it that way, but it is one of those songs that can be imagined to not actually be singing of Oz, but instead of Heaven, which in my mind makes it a bit more special than it otherwise would be. One thing I can say, I don't think I have ever heard a song by a teenager which will ever sound so good to me. I will always remember it and feel I have really been blessed when out of nowhere I hear it some place. I'm not a big listener of Judy Garland, but i have never heard her sing anything that was even half as appealing as that song has been. One hit wonder pretty much,
I have to agree with you Charles_22. I was born in '59 too, and my mother was a huge fan of Judy Garland and daughter Liza Minelli so I got to hear both... alot! Judy's best was definately "SOtR" I don't think she ever reached that plateau in her singing again. As for daughter Liza, IMO she lived off her mothers fame; not my cup of tea.
Jeff
Boy, shows how much I know about the old stars. I had no idea Liza was her daughter. I always couldn't stand Liza, though I guess she did well enough in the Arthur movies.
I heard SoTR on a local radio station a couple of times recently and then after I wrote the earlier post I listened to that sing on youtube, actually from the movie. She still sounded good, but not half as good as what I heard on the radio. I suppose the version I heard on the radio was a new cut single when she got older, and I mistaked that for WoO version. Can you imagine how many thousands of times she had to sing that song? Actually in the movie she sings it before she goes to Oz, so that lends a little more credence to the notion that it's a song about Heaven instead. As I said, I doubt that was the intent, but it is inevitably a song about getting away from the hurt of the present world.
|
Printable Version
RE: The world according to the french - 
New Messages
No New Messages
Hot Topic w/ New Messages
Hot Topic w/o New Messages
Locked w/ New Messages
Locked w/o New Messages
Post New Thread