Ursa MAior
Posts: 1416
Joined: 4/20/2005 From: Hungary, EU Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: 06 Maestro A national ID could be beneficial for the U.S. The problem is that the government is not trusted to do the right thing with its new data bank. We have a government which wants to give various Id's to illegals, including drivers licenses. What difference will a new photo card make? Could it be counterfeited? Will there be corrupt officials that hand them out to illegals? I don't like being so pessimistic, but under the circumstances, I have no choice. If I understand the situation correctly, in the E.U., people are allowed to move about freely between the member states-for work or to actually relocate. I assume it would be quite difficult for a Hungarian policeman to tap into German data banks to check out someone who claims to be German. With an EU wide system, that would not be a problem. Under those new European circumstances, an EU ID card would make sense. As for a national ID card for Hungarians, I suppose that would be helpful also due to the myriad of borders and nation states in the area. It is still open to abuse, and apparently has not stopped illegal immigration into various European states. If the U.S. government was to do a few things-like make an earnest effort to seal the southern border to terrorists and migrants, then I would be more inclined to support a national ID card, but it probably wouldn't be necessary then. The pols like to babble about "comprehensive" reform this, that and the other. When the politicians start talking "comprehensive", they are really saying "obfuscate", "delay", and "bury". We row in the same boat. I lost my faith in the govt, which only acts in its interests and not ours e.g. we are in the middle of reforms which in reality were started only to cover how bad they really were at governing. As of IDs there is corruption (like everywhere unfortunately), but the majority of the people is still trustworthy (albeit not for too long I think), so it could have its uses. As of illegal immigrants yes most of them goes to other cutries to milk the system so should be treated as such se the recent case of the murderd woman by a rumanian in Rome. Even in Germany people are thinking about setting up camps for criminals under 14 yrs (mostly illegal immigrants) cuz according to the law they cannot be punished under 14. But they have to be restrained somehow from commiting more crimes. It is not a good idea but there is not any better. As of politicians. I dunno how is it in the US but here (in Hungary) we cannot make our politicians responsible even when acting completely against their program (for fulfilling which they were elected). Probably we will need a new constitution cuz the current patched up version of the communist one is far from ideal. Maybe a new way of selecting polticians should be invented. For me they representate themselves, then the people who supported their election, and only rarely the will of the people who elected them.
< Message edited by Ursa MAior -- 1/14/2008 3:35:53 PM >
_____________________________
Art by the amazing Dixie
|