Grollub
Posts: 6674
Joined: 10/9/2005 From: Lulea, Sweden Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: Chickenboy quote:
ORIGINAL: Grollub quote:
ORIGINAL: Chickenboy quote:
ORIGINAL: Grollub quote:
ORIGINAL: gladiatt quote:
ORIGINAL: sprior Work from home day! would like to. 10 to 20 inch of snow expected in a few hours before i get back home..... Hmmm ... that doesn't sound so good. I'm going for a recce to the Ardennes area (IVO Sedan) on friday morning and staying until sunday. Was hoping for a little better weather :-/ Well, it should be perfect for your students, Per. I mean, lousy snowing weather in the Ardennes in November or December. No one would launch a major offensive in that weather in that place. True ... But then, we will go there with our students coming May ... This is an interesting point. From an military educational perspective, which Ardennes battle do you feel is most critical to show your students on site and why? I'll give you a true staff officer answer; "That depends ... [on what points/things/themes you want to teach or discuss]" ... It also depends on what meaning you put in the word "battle" - Low level skirmish? A campaign? In this particular case however, we're will mainly look at the 1940 campaign and the values of "Auftragstaktik (/"Mission type orders")" and wargaming an operational plan to name just a few points among many. The asymmetry between French and German doctrines that paved the way for the outcome is also interesting to discuss. Having access to relevant background material from both sides and trying to understand why the commanders made the decisions they made, and doing it in the actual terrain where they made those, is also invaluable. Then, trying to synthezise those lessons learned into something that has relevance nowadays (or in the future) is also something that we always do. We've going to have to change the structure of this trip for various reasons, so that's why we are going on a new recce. Given how many battles that has been (historically) fought in that area however, I wouldn't be surprised if we happen to find some new interesting "stop". Some years ago, we had a (from the 1940 campaign) deviating stop at Bastogne, where the theme for discussion was "tenacity" One other stop that hasn't got anything to with 1940 is at Verdun, where we will discuss "consequences". A sobering place to discuss that theme.
_____________________________
“Not mastering metaphores is like cooking pasta when the train is delayed"
|