mind_messing
Posts: 3393
Joined: 10/28/2013 Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: Lowpe quote:
ORIGINAL: mind_messing Where would you rather defend? As I've said, you can't ram anywhere near as many aircraft onto the Bonin's and if the Allies get on Luzon, they can work up towards Formosa and Okinawa with just land-based aircraft. The Marianas are a unique oppertunity to fight the Allied CV force without Allied LBA in support. I think that if you don't shoot the farm on the Marianas, later defences will be so much harder as the Allies are bombing your production into ashes turn after turn. All good points. I would rather be fighting in Oz and the Gilberts in 45, like Topeverest's game, but oh well... Keep in mind that topeverest's game has juiced Japan out of the ball-park. quote:
I was curious if you could build up the Marianas so much the Allies go another route...something like what is happening in Wargamr's AAR up thru SRA into China and Luzon. I think that depends on your opponent. The attraction of the Marianas is two fold: - The bases can be built up quite large and (both for future invasions and for B-29 bombing) and are isolated from Japanese counter-attacks and raids. - They simplify logistics - once Wake is captured/suppressed the Allies can ship from the West Coast to PH then directly to the Marianas. Put it quite simply, if the Allies decide not to go for the Marianas, the only other real options they can go for are the Kuriles or to try to work towards Luzon. quote:
I think I would rather fight there...I especially like Luzon, with railroads, multiple airbases, some safe from shore bombardment, railroads...in fact there are several size 8 or soon to be 8's runways on Luzon now. All that glitters is not gold. The same is true of Luzon. It looks nice, with the inland airbases and the railroad connections, but you have to think about the rest of the PI. There are dozens of islands south of Luzon with good airbase potentials, and you can't hope to defend them all. When the Allies come for Luzon, they can take several of these islands and start building airbases quicker than you can bomb them. Once the airbases are up, escorted 4E's will be able to start pounding Luzon into dust, the Allied battleships can get LR-CAP for bombardment runs and the USN fleet carriers are left free to do what they will. See Obvert and Joc's AAR for a good example of this. Compare that with the Marianas, where the only aircraft that can reach the islands are 4E's and any battleship bombardments need carrier escorts to be possible. That's not to say that Luzon shouldn't be as much of a fortress as you can make it, just to say that there are better places to have your line in the sand. quote:
I don't think you will see a contested invasion against an atoll without heavy disruption among the defenders. There is a possibility you will see that kind of fight against a larger Island? Don't know. Didn't Loka invade Wake relatively early on against you? I'm not sure that's the case. When Loka raided Wake, the aviation unit and the CD unit drew most of the distruption and left the two combat units in reasonable condition. With a larger island = more units = harder job to deal out disruption. At least, that's what I hope. CD units seem to absorb distruption for other units, keep the bombarding ships honest and deal some damage to troops unloading. There's no forced shock attack for larger islands, but there is the defender's auto-bombard to think about.
|