56ajax
Posts: 1950
Joined: 12/3/2007 From: Carnegie, Australia Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: No idea The problem is in the "win" concept most players have. If you have played this game for a long time, you end up accepting that winning as the germans against a similar skill opponent means holding a line in Russia when the game ends in 1945. The problem is that most players out there dont see that as winning, so they dont like to play as Germany. On top of that, it requires more skill, as it is extremely painful, against a similar skill soviet player, to commit any mistake during the first turn. I have to say I understand both points of view, after having played the game for two years, but, if the game wants to appeal to a wider audience (something good for bussiness) then it needs to make things more balanced based and less reality based, imho, giving the germans more opportunities to really win than irl. I generally agree with your comments and thats why I try to find German opponents who like playing the game as opposed to winning at all costs. My current opponent wanted to play an historical game and I was happy to oblige. Whilst his opening turn was a touch too generous I responded by counter attacking as much as possible instead of running away. Counter attacking is useless btw but it was inline with the spirit of our house rules. I tend not to play as the german as it is much more technical and a move like the Lvov pocket I find ridiculous. I would be reluctant to move away from an historical game because it is not a fantasy game, but the Russo german war, though there is room for whatif scenarios like others have said. Perhaps one of the problems with the game is that no one plays as incompetently as the Russians fought in 1941
|