Slitherine

quote:

ORIGINAL: Alvaro Sousa

Convoy routes are only for resources not supplies. Ports get supplies and are affected by units near them.

If you want to stop ships and planes raiding your port supply place other ships and planes in the area. Also attack and sink them.

quote:

ORIGINAL: Alvaro Sousa

All you have to do is part a fleet outside the port. That's it.

quote:

ORIGINAL: Meteor2

Thanks nnc1701e for all the „Research“ you are doing here.
Especially these naval aspects have to be right and meaningful, before going to the PTO.

quote:

ORIGINAL: sveint

quote:

ORIGINAL: Alvaro Sousa

All you have to do is part a fleet outside the port. That's it.

Sorry but this must be explicitly stated somewhere in the manual. I was completely unaware of it.

quote:

ORIGINAL: ncc1701e

Alvaro, I like your convoy routes system. This is elegant, simple and transparent. But, at the same time, I have to say that the port supply system is opaque.

Why don't you add two things in the below window?

1. The number of transport ships used to supply one port. The "1 transport for 1 port unlimited supply amount" rule is a little too simple. Maybe 1 transport for 1 port for 40 supplies would be better. Like this, Tripoli (120) needs 3 transport ships instead of one. And, if in a port supply interdiction a message is shown saying I have lost 40 stockpile, then you sunk 1 transport ship from the pool.

2. Allow the player to assign escorts on port supply routes just like you are doing for convoy routes.

Thanks

quote:

ORIGINAL: Alvaro Sousa

I had that before and it just added micromanagement and mistakes. I kept it simple so players can focus on thinking.

quote:

Supply Convoy Raider - Air units within 8 hexes, or fewer if their range is shorter, of an enemy port that have remaining operation points at the end of their turn might intercept and attack the supply convoy of an enemy and reduce its stockpile for the port.

quote:

Supply Convoy Attacks - Naval units near an enemy port that has its port supply active are subject to having their supply convoys attacked. Transports may be sunk when raiding a supply convoy. The closer a fleet is to the enemy port, the higher chance of intercepting the supply convoy. A naval unit must be within 4 hexes of the enemy port to have any chance of affecting the supply convoy. The supply interdiction targets the port capacity. A port can’t be reduced below 1 from a supply convoy attack.

quote:

Supply Convoy Interdiction - After supply is calculated for a port, friendly and enemy fleets are automatically calculated for interdicting the supply line. Port supplies can be affected by enemy naval and air forces in the area with at least 1 operation point at the end of the turn. Naval forces need to be within 4 hexes and enemy air forces within 8 hexes, or less if the air unit range is less, of the port to have a chance to affect supply delivered. Friendly air and naval forces automatically escort within the same ranges. Port levels can’t be reduced lower than 1. The further away an interdicting enemy fleet is from the enemy port, the less chance the fleet has to interdict the supplies. There is a small chance a transport point will get sunk if the supply convoy is interdicted. Escorts have no such penalty as they are considered as being with the supply transport coming into the port.

quote:

Submarine Fleet - Submarine units may base at a port with other naval units but may only travel outside the port with other submarine units. Submarine fleets may be attacked by surface fleets only if they border a non-ocean hex. Carrier fleets and air units may always attack submarine fleets.

quote:

ORIGINAL: Manstein63

For an example supply goes to Tobruk from Italy every turn is there anyway you can turn off the supply so that it stops going from Italy to Tobruk
Manstein63

quote:

ORIGINAL: ncc1701e

And, when ships are attacking / defending, they should be damaged sometimes. As such, could you please add the information of the ships that have participated in the fight and have taken losses during the supply convoy attack?

quote:

ORIGINAL: Alvaro Sousa
I did add that subs are hit with ASW during this turn because surface ships can't openly attack them.

quote:


As for the rest... I'll think about it.

quote:

ORIGINAL: Alvaro Sousa

That's why you attack the other navy. I do not want to force engagements and have players scream bloody murder. It is the players responsibility that if X fleet is disrupting your supply lines you should be attacking it on your turn. And they can do the same to you.

I did add that subs are hit with ASW during this turn because surface ships can't openly attack them.

quote:

ORIGINAL: Alvaro Sousa

Only things that can't be done manually will be automatic combat.
ASW vs subs ** this has been added as of yesterday
air sups vs bombers

manually on your turn...
air vs surface/CV
surface vs surface
CV vs CV

quote:

Submarine Fleet - Submarine units may base at a port with other naval units but may only travel outside the port with other submarine units. Submarine fleets may be attacked by surface fleets only if they border a non-ocean hex. Carrier fleets and air units may always attack submarine fleets.